More on martyrs Tom Smith
Maimon has below a typically fascinating post on martyrdom and its difficulties. Put me in the category of people who think no Canadian, safe among the forests and fish of that blessed land, has any business criticizing two journalists who elected to do their campy imitations of Muslims, rather than have their heads sawn off with dull knives. It does, however, raise the question of when martyrdom becomes the right thing to do, and whether it is ever morally required.
Martyrdom tends to get defined too broadly in our imprecise age. The word actually comes from the Greek word for something like “eye witness” — that is, a personal witness to some event. Martyr came to mean someone who witnessed to his faith by suffering death rather than renouncing it. It came also to cover missionaries who died in the field, by being boiled in big caldrons and the like, and perhaps also to those who died of disease, shipwreck and other hazards of the missionary business.
The classical martyrdom is a peculiar thing. Many Christian martyrs in antiquity died rather than do precisely what they would have been forbidden to do were they Jews, which was to worship at the feet of some Roman god or other. Often persecutors were crafty in demanding just what they knew their victims were forbidden to do. Witness the ultimate boxing in of Thomas More. It makes one wonder what is so special about some form of words, or burning a lamb chop in front of the partially nude figure of some Roman he-god. What’s the biggie? Especially if God knows you are doing it strictly to avoid some truly gruesome fate, such as being dipped in pitch and used as a human torch, or that old standby, crucifixion. We may think these things would be bad, but really, we have no idea. I fear there is not much chance that I would have lit the Apennine Way; more likely I would have asked, do you want that lamb chop rare or what?
Commentators who ridicule others for “cowardice” for not dying as martyrs for secular humanism, or whatever it is Fox journalists profess, are silly in the extreme. As has been pointed out, nobody thinks forcing hapless journalists to “convert” to Islam displays anything more than the depravity of the terrorists and their ill mastery of even the most basic principles of public relations. Neither would it prove much were a journalist or other hostage choose to die. Personal courage, to be sure, but we already know Americans are willing to give their lives to defeat the terrorists. They’re doing that every day in Iraq, among other places. The Roman martyrs, and the Japanese martyrs among many others, were making particular points. They were demonstrating in the most graphic way possible that it is possible not to be intimidated by the apparatus of terror, and since courage is contagious, eventually, one hopes, terror will fall before enough people who won’t be terrorized. It doesn’t always work. It would be different if you were a cleric, perhaps, or a professional moral leader, but nowadays, if you’re just a civilian, I for one don’t think you are morally required to die or be tortured, rather than mouth what the terrorists want you to say. On the other hand, you might choose to refuse to, and die, just to piss them off. It’s your call. Maybe you should die like an Italian.
There is something profound I am not managing to capture about how martyrs make suffering and dying a symbolic act. One thinks of Christ on the cross, of course, but it also makes me think of something very different, how one legend has it that the samurai custom of sepuku originated, or so I read in one of the innumerable books on samurai that clutter our household. Supposedly, a castle being defended by samurai was about to be overwhelmed by warriors from another clan. One samurai (who I have also read was regarded as completely insane) stood on the walls, jeered at the obviously soon to be victorious enemy, then cut himself open, pulled out his guts, and threw them down at his horrified enemies. Quite a radical thing to do, but articulate– it says I hold suffering, death and you, all in equal contempt. Stranger still that it became a ritual, if you believe the story. Me, I regard a too tight belt as a terrible trial.