Another Campus Bias Story Gail Heriot
Here’s a charming story told to NoIndoctrination.org by a student from the University of Wisconsin at La Crosse. (NoIndoctrination.org, by the way, is a web site at which students may comment on classroom bias.):
“Let me begin by saying that I received an AB [GPA 3.5] in this course, so this posting isn’t harshness triggered by a bad grade.
All of Dr. Betton’s lectures centered around pushing his viewpoint and what he felt was right. Complex and debatable issues like global warming, corporate social responsibility, nanotechnology, immigration, etc. were geared to his one viewpoint. When our class was studying immigration and reading only pro-immigration (liberal) readings, I sent my professor links to a few viewpoints that oppose his views. Here is my exact email to Dr. Betton:
On Nov 1, 2006, at 3:25 PM, [Student] wrote:
here is are a few articles that present the detriment of immigration to the United Statesfirst one is a complete anti-immigration
http://www.frontpagemag.com/Articles/ReadArticle.asp?ID=1836and the 2nd one is something i would really like you to consider adding to give a conservative view to immigration
http://www.phxnews.com/fullstory.php?article=7205thanks for reading
tony———
Dr. Betton’s exact email response:From: Betton John H
Sent: Wed 11/1/2006 5:51 PM
To: [Student]
Subject: Re: takes from the ‘other side’ to consider on illegal immigrationI get really tired of right wing stuff. Surely you get enough of it. Do you ask for additional readings in your right wing classes. Obviously not. I resent your insulting assumption that you have the right to teach my class or that students are not familiar with right wing racist crap on immigration. Of course they are. My course is not being taught to reinforce right wing ideology. Don’t you get enough of this in other classes, or do you need EVERY class to be consistent with extremist views.
Nothing happened during class to make Dr. Betton conduct his email in this manner. This email proves a liberal bias of ‘excessive’ nature!”
A few years ago, when the NoIndoctrination.org web site was new, it received a bit of publicity and thus a large number of postings from frustrated students. Lately, it has gotten fewer. I hope this is because the number of cases of abuse is declining, but I don’t have any reason to believe that’s the case.