How the Media Fell for A Racism Sham – by Jesse Singal
Unsurprisingly, major media outlets were all over this story. The Times coverage set the tone, with the Washington Post and CNN and Sports Illustrated and NPR all publishing similar articles, alongside the predictable think pieces. The incident also had consequences for BYU sports more generally. The head coach of women s basketball at the University of South Carolina canceled its home opener against BYU. A match between Duke and Rider University s women s volleyball teams scheduled to be played at the BYU arena was moved to a nearby high school gym in order to provide both teams the safest atmosphere, according to Duke s Director of Athletics, Nina King.
For millions of people watching this story unfold, this was yet another example of the ineradicable stain of American racism, of just how little progress we ve really made.
Except it didn t happen.
There is no evidence that the chain of events described by Richardson and her family members occurred. There isn t even evidence a single slur was hurled at her and her teammates, let alone a terrifying onslaught of them.
All the journalists who credulously reported on this event were wrong and it was an embarrassing kind of wrong, because the red flags were large, numerous, and flapping loudly. Richardson and her family members reported that racial slurs had been hurled with abandon, loudly and repeatedly, in a crowded gym filled with more than 5,000 people. But the journalists covering this incident never stopped to notice how odd it was that none of these vile slurs were captured by any of the thousands of little handheld cameras in the gym at the time, nor on the bigger cameras recording the match. Nor did they find it strange that in the days following the incident, not a single other eyewitness came forward none of Richardson s black teammates, and none of the players for either team.